reese wonders
16 years ago
if prenatal genetic testing and genetic counseling are really thinly veiled eugenic practices more than helpful tools?
latest #17
Chat Suspecte
16 years ago
I wonder this myself
reese says
16 years ago
True, that.
KDFrawg 🐸
16 years ago
That is one part of a very large ethical debate...
立即下載
reese hates
16 years ago
that my *former* OB-GYN prodded people into aborting pregnancies that showed certain genetic testing results. I'm glad she's out-of-business
Nanners©
16 years ago
depends on what you mean by eugenics but I don't see it as veiled so much as walking a tightrope on individual choices about children.
Άτροπος
16 years ago
I think it largely depends on the care provider … and in the US, the profit margin. I imagine there will be potential parents who will use
Άτροπος
16 years ago
testing to "weed out undesirables," while others will use it to try to find therapies that could make the eventual baby's life better.
Titter says
16 years ago
it does really depend on "what for"...like breast cancer genetic testing is definitely valuable
Titter says
16 years ago
ooops...missed the "prenatal" part of that :/ sorry
Thegovernment genetic database will be used to cull genetically-desirable human specimens for the pre-meteor strike trip to Mars.
Άτροπος is
16 years ago
a genetic dead-end, anyway, so it's kind of academic for me.
Nanners©
16 years ago
when I hear the word "eugenics" it usually carries the connotation of group or societal coercion so it runs smack into whether parents
Nanners©
16 years ago
are pressured to avoid babies with certain 'defects' or diseases on one side and into the abortion debate on the other.
Grumba says
16 years ago
you have to be kidding! It's far too difficult and time consuming to be part of some socalled 'plot'- you must take a WORLD view.
Muttley says
16 years ago
possibly. It may be more "your kid may have expensive to treat syndrome X, we don't want to have to pay for that."
EvilBenFranklin
16 years ago
It wouldn't surprise me, but I don't think it's the government. I think it's the insurance industry not wanting to pay for expensive care.
back to top