hi matt. you are awesome.

it's not Failing Dawn. it's Failing Fail.

it's not all childish, you know. there are serious reasons why that book is not a great one.

it contradicts its prequels, it has little to no character development, it's overloaded with details, which makes it boring

I applaud your efforts, Matt.

It's Breaking Dawn = Epic Fail

However, I do applaud you

yeah. I agree with your issues with the book. however, I think it inappropriate and childish to say that. But that is just me.

thank you, Rosa. i agree. maybe you just express your opinions in a different way, Matt.

I'm guessing you liked it though?

no offense, but we can call it what we like and you can call it what you like.

how about that?

I'm cool with that if everyone else is XD

agrees with Matt on this one. Even though I haven't read Twilight, this could be taken as childish to an extent.

I never said you couldn't call it whatever you want Olivia. I wasn't attacking you in any way. You just feel one way, and I feel different.

I can express my feelings too

i never said you couldn't. that was the poit of that response. we call it what we want and you call it what you want.

*point, sorry

guys, it's a book. if you don't like it, fine. if you do, fine. just stop fighting over it.

Hello Matt. I agree completely with you

Eh. I think the beginning is just Failing Dawn. After that it doesn't completely suck

thank you for attempting to be a voice of reason.

I could not agree more with Matt. Good job, mate

if Matt enjoyed the book?

well, I haven't read it, so I have no opinion either way, but it makes me very sad when people argue

well, i for one enjoyed it!

as did I!!!

^join my facebook group

what is the name of the group hufflepuffwin?

hey matt? when's the next imprint gonna come out??

"I liked Breaking Dawn"

nermalasu ^^^

Good Job Matt

can now read this thread bec. I finally finished the book. It was fine- just like the other ones. None of them are literary works of genius

But it was still entertaining. I happened to like the twist that most other people didn't, but that is just me. All in all not disappointing

but that might be because I wasn't putting soooo much stock in it anyway. Twilight is what it is. Sorry for hijacking this thread

thank you Penny. You always seem to have the same opinion as me.

I could come up with a funny reason why that is...