L'fuckingChaim
9 months ago
I'm not saying the Azim Steppe is perfect, but reading an analysis of GRRM's Dothraki vs actual horse nomads, clearly someone at SE did more research (any at all)
latest #23
L'fuckingChaim
9 months ago
since we have:
L'fuckingChaim
9 months ago
-multiple cultures/ethnic groups, with clearly different cultures
L'fuckingChaim
9 months ago
(everyone speaks the same language, though)
立即下載
L'fuckingChaim
9 months ago
-clothing made largely of textiles, with bright colors and decoration because people like to look nice
L'fuckingChaim
9 months ago
(...and whatever Sadu and the Buduga think they're doing. it's NOT perfect, but it's not Dothraki "plain brown leather and horsehair trousers")
Un(t)sundered
9 months ago
an effort was made! an imperfect effort, but there was research
L'fuckingChaim
9 months ago
-a mixture of sheep pastoralism and dzo (bisonish) hunting as primary subsistence methods
ADELEDJI’D
9 months ago
Azim Steppe feels like the most I’ve seen anyone actually try wrt central Asian horse nomads that wasn’t, like, clearly someone with a degree writing historical fiction
L'fuckingChaim
9 months ago
there was research! rather than exclusively dredging up hollywood stereotypes and claiming that there was "a dash of pure fantasy"
L'fuckingChaim
9 months ago
it really is
ADELEDJI’D
9 months ago
I mean it’s not a very big reference pool but
L'fuckingChaim
9 months ago
the bar is, to be clear, on the floor, but
L'fuckingChaim
9 months ago
ironically they aren't either horse or nomads in FFXIV - those dwellings are definitely permanent structures, by the size and weight of components
L'fuckingChaim
9 months ago
yol pastoralists
L'fuckingChaim
9 months ago
also:
L'fuckingChaim
9 months ago
-music and art
paradisaea
9 months ago
to be fair to the singular language thing I can excuse it with a dash of "language barriers seem to largely not exist on eitheirys at all"
L'fuckingChaim
9 months ago
between that and the Echo and the "shh they all speak Player", yeah
paradisaea
9 months ago
and in a game where the player speaks Beaver, you know what, we'll allow it.
language barriers only exist in relevance to meracydia since arr which is deeply funny to me.
Un(t)sundered
9 months ago
yeah, I assume there's probably like... a trade language between the tribes (or those who actually speak)
Un(t)sundered
9 months ago
and the WoL is shortcutting with Echo nonsense
Nancy Crawfish
9 months ago
I love that they have so many cultures
back to top