really frustrated by this form of evangelism and I don't think I can grade this fairly.

this is where Toulmin comes to the rescue - what are her warrants for this claim? I'm guessing she assumes "everyone is looking for God"

and doesn't even attempt to defend that claim

sat in on an adjunct's class last week, and he said, "If you write an argument that I can't grade fairly, then I won't grade it fairly."

that response, KiWi. And FB, I'm thinking you just gave me a basis for some quality comments.