So, IF you were in Carl's position, what would you have done? Killed the girl or let her live or what?

idkw hat I would have done...

i would have ended her

mishaselene: hi5

KIILLLL ALL PSYCOPATHS

it's cold, but she honestly is mentally ill enough, that she can not distinguish right from wrong

BUT , y'all are so evil... she might have been just going through a crazy phase..and ye kill a young girl

how is anyone going to be safe around her, ever

Mayeb I would have .. like.. Tied her up in a barn or something, fed her daily like an animal, and see how her condirtiongoes

yep... sorry.. you can't secure the others from her all the time forever, she's a liability

she's been getting worse, not better as time has gone on

Misha, I told him. He thinks I am cold for thinking the same way as you

Im just saying..well Inex, yer Argument is that she is a full blown psychopath

which she may be, but ye can't tell , she was just blokcing otu everything, and it manifested itself

Inex: i know that's why Carol ended her, because Tyrese probably couldn't have done it

Not full blowns, she's young but she's going there

idk, hard to know

I am loving Carol now. Bitch does what needs to be done

If I ever kill my sister I will be sure not to telkl you guys

she killed her little sister with the intent of her coming back as a 'friend'

And was about to kill the baby so Yeeeaaaah

ehh, still couldnt kill a kid

;/

she had no concept of the danger, nor of the fact that she's been playing with fire, and her lack of empathy for other living humans, was going to get her and other people killed

i'd kill her, dont worry

She had more empathy for the dead than the living

ehhh

idk, I still cant say id kill her

it is liek askign, if ye coudl go back in time to when Hitler was a baby, woudl you kill it?

Cos if nurtured differnetly, it woudl have been a diff outcome

most likely

Oriongant: are you going to sit there for the next 30 + years, nurturing that child?

and sorry, there's very little room for kids to be just kids in the new order of things in that world

well I wouldn't, but I wouldn't kill a baby

but well, look at Karl

burtured right with his dad and stuff, not beign crazy.. He could have easily gone that way though.

it's temperment, mentality, etc... each kid is different and each kid is going to handle it differently

but i have this feeling that Lizzie had issues before all this came about, and was getting some help of sorts

and now... she's not

Now she is just Lenny from of mice and men

got no time for crazy BS during the apocalypse, Carol did the right thing

^

you lot are such evil mofos

not evil... pragmatic

sometimes in extreme circumstances... it's the lesser of evils

Tyreese is a little girl when it comes to...pretty much anything. Carol did what had to be done in order to ensure that the little psycho-nut couldn't take out any more innocents.