Golly, can't imagine what some of these answers might be.

"Everything" is so broad.

His lack of love for icecream

"Caro, would it kill you to smile?"

jjabarrett: You mean his lack of admitting he loves ice cream, yes?

FloralunaAria: His smile is terrible, Feli. You don't want it.

Yeah. That one. The truth right there.

He can't be seen liking ice cream when he's gonna look 12 for a couple hundred years okay, geez.

That's a lame excuse

and he should just always love ice cream

and be open about it

But it will make him look more like a kid when he's not! This is so important!

the crushingly low self esteem

Pot to the kettle, right Tony?

That poor little makeshift family had so many self-worth issues.

oh my god right?

look he knows he's a hypocrite

but you deserve better Nathan :c

im so late but omg is his smile really that bad?

IT'S KIND OF CREEPY.

IM LAUGHING ITS BC OF HIS DEAD EYES

like if it werent for his eyes his smile would just look mischievous

but his eyes

Yup. There is no smile of his that doesn't look at least vaguely disturbing.

Be glad he doesn't smile more, basically.

omg aufihasiugh

I remember one time he did smile in-game, and the other character said: "You have got to learn how to make normal-person facial expressions. You look like a fucking demon when you do that."

snorts oh poor thing

Pfff, as if his feelings were hurt.

I mean, his least unsettling smile, I think might be . . .

And that's still kind of off. Probably because he looks like a damn ghost.

aw that last one actually looks cute

It's probably his best one, but he just looks so ghostly.