Also the PhD programs seem to have a requirement for your dissertations where you have "a chapter of at least 75 pages that locates the work in its literary and historical contexts" . Around that sort of thing.
Then again, my master's thesis one of my directors said that she never thought fantasy fiction could read like a serious novel. And it was horribly fan-fictiony at times.
It's really just the idea of having to write something serious and scholarly about something that may contain Alec in all his Gary Stuness or Ceilidh and Princess Stabbity.