realistically damian would probably get annoyed
faith would like to be called beautiful sincerely (she's hot and she knows it but she doesn't consider herself beautiful) but its too close to sincerity so she'd just laugh. aelwyn's thinking "oh, you're like stupid stupid."
i think being called beautiful sincerely would probably make ianthe feel some things but you won't know it by the vaguely smug expression (she is coronabeth's starved shadow, the unpleasant twin). chara is just like "TIME TO CHANGE YOUR MIND"
i did a doubletake at the karolina icons